Maslow’s hierarchy of needs vs. the Republican pyramid of political values

You may have heard of Abraham Maslow’s hierarchy of human needs. He cites five levels of growth, beginning with what a newborn infant needs and moving on to self-actualization, which is the top level of the pyramid. Maslow describes self-actualization this way:

This level of need refers to what a person’s full potential is and the realization of that potential…the desire to accomplish everything that one can, to become the most that one can be. Individuals may perceive or focus on this need very specifically. For example, one individual may have the strong desire to become an ideal parent. In another, the desire may be expressed athletically. For others, it may be expressed in paintings, pictures, or inventions.

MaslowsHierarchyOfNeeds-aAs you can see from the pyramid above, self-actualization comes after love/belonging and esteem. Maslow asserts that one cannot achieve self-actualization until he/she has secured the previous four needs.

What does this have to do with politics? In order to address this question, I have created a comparable hierarchy of public citizen needs.

common good is at the top of the political hierarchy pyramid The parallels between the two pyramids are as below. The explanations in the third column are important.

Parallels-aThe key component is that, for a public citizen to be fully actualized, he or she must have the ability to go beyond personal and group loyalties and to move to an awareness and concern for the common good. When progressives are not burdened with impulses to be snarky and nasty, they set the example for how to care about the general good. They want human and economic rights to be protected for all citizens, while working toward justice and fairness in the rules and laws that govern our society. They make every effort to not make decisions based on personal or parochial interests but rather on what proves the greatest good for the greatest number of people.

Reaching the highest level, “caring about common good,” generally requires an individuald to look both inside and around themselves. They must feel comfortable taking risks and sacrifice personal gains for the well-being of others.

This is where the rubber meets the road when it comes to Republicans. They can get four-fifths of the way up the pyramid. It is easy for them to care about their own country and their own religion as well as other group affiliations that are “theirs.” But when it gets beyond oneself, that is where growth tends to be stunted. The graph below illustrates:

GOP-Political-pyramid-smallThis is why we have members of the so-called “Freedom Caucus” advocating shut-downs of the federal government and Groundhog Day repetitions of trying to repeal the Affordable Care Act (without offering any alternative solutions). They simply do not care about the common good. Other Republicans may not resort to such extremes, but they repeatedly block attempts to weave a tight safety net for those among us who need help.

More and more is being written about the Republican brain. There is general agreement that the cut-off for many Republicans is taking the final step to an awareness of what is the common good and how that must be a cornerstone of political decision-making.

What is still baffling to this writer is why and how the mainstream press refuses to point out this dichotomy and operates with false equivalencies between progressive and conservative positions. Perhaps the movie “Truth” about Dan Rather and Mary Mapes of CBS News will present some insight on this issue.

  • Anthony

    I vote based on Maslow’s Hierarchy. All I need from the government is to keep my family safe from foreign threats. Anything else just gets in my way. Safety is towards the bottom of the pyramid. I can rise to the top on my own.

  • Dr. Travis Hedrick

    Amazingly enough, despite the obvious political bias of the writer, I can agree with his assumption that a Republican is unlikely to ever achieve the Pinnacle of the Pyramid.

    I would like to point out, that while often disguised as the upper 3 spaces in the pyramid, Democrats, especially liberal and progressives, can never achieve anything higher then the 2nd level and most will never emerge from the 1st.

    Democrats/Liberals make boisterous claims for society and others, but it is all usually a smokescreen for the fact that is really all about themselves, their careers, their pocketbooks, and occasionally their close family members. This is a true insight into the mind of a liberal – the ability to disassociate facts and truth from their perceived realities.

    However, to be completely transparent and fair… representing only about 4% of Americans completely, both Democrats and Republicans are slaves to their own agenda, political platforms, and rarely engage the will of the rest of the 96% of Americans who they were elected to represent!

  • Pingback: We can learn a lot from the President and Hillary Clinton about how to respond to Trump - Occasional Planet()

  • Pingback: Guide For Talking To Irrational People: Whispering To The Elephant | Intentional Insights()

  • Artyom Rechtman

    It’s very funny that the author didn’t realize this pyramid is Republican in itself. It’s much easier to imagine, for example, a liberal, who stands against the whole concepts of “family”, “country” and “religion”, and absolutely impossible — a conservative.